Everything online journalists need to protect their legal rights. This free resource culls from all Reporters Committee resources and includes exclusive content on digital media law issues.
Correction 10/19/1993
An October 11 article on a Michigan Supreme Court ruling that the secret search for a new college president violated the state's open records law incorrectly identified the name of the college. The school involved was the University of Michigan. The name of the case was correct: Booth Newspapers v. The Board of Regents of the University of Michigan.
KENTUCKY -- The Kentucky Court of Appeals in Frankfort reversed a five-year sentence imposed on the publisher of a small newspaper who was convicted of using dealer license plates on his car to avoid automobile taxes and registration fees. In an opinion published in late August, the court upheld the conviction but remanded the case to the circuit court for resentencing.
Robert Harrell, publisher of Tell It Like It Is, an irregularly published tabloid based in Henderson, has asked the court for a rehearing.
MICHIGAN -- The state Supreme Court ruled in late September that the secret search for a new president of Michigan State University violated the state's open meetings and freedom of information laws.
The Board of Regents, the public body that appointed itself as the Presidential Selection Committee, improperly closed its deliberations and decisions and held private interviews with candidates in violation of the Open Meetings Act, the justices ruled.
CALIFORNIA -- Four months after upholding a contempt citation against Rik Scarce -- a sociology doctoral student at Washington State University jailed since May 14 for refusing to answer grand jury questions about the animal liberation movement -- in mid- September the U.S. Court of Appeals in San Francisco (9th Cir.) issued an opinion explaining its holding.
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- A freshman congressman from Oklahoma in late September won a battle to scrap the House of Representatives' 63- year-old tradition of secrecy surrounding discharge petitions, which are filed by representatives who want bills stuck in committee brought to the House floor for action.
VIRGINIA -- The Fairfax County Board of Supervisors directed its staff in late September to find "a legal way" to ban distribution of the Washington Blade, a free gay newspaper, at the county library, or to abolish the Library Board of Trustees.
The Virginia Chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union has written in protest to the board, calling the vote "an appalling act of governmental censorship and an abuse of authority."
GEORGIA -- A Superior Court judge ruled in late September that the police may withhold some details in several incident reports pertaining to an apparent serial rapist in Brunswick.
Three incident reports should be released with the dates, time and street locations of the rapes, the judge ruled from the bench. Information such as the age and race of the victims or more specific details about the location of the crime, whether it occurred in a car or a house, should be kept secret, the judge ruled.
NEW YORK -- In late September the U.S. Court of Appeals in New York (2nd Cir.) upheld a defense lawyer's subpoena to journalists seeking notes and outtakes of filmed interviews with the lawyer, who has been charged with criminal contempt. In 1990 and 1991 the lawyer, Bruce Cutler, had sharply criticized the government's prosecution of his client, the notorious New York organized crime figure John Gotti.
WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The federal government can keep secret most of a report that details the wartime activities of Kurt Waldheim, former secretary-general of the United Nations and former president of Austria, the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington, D.C., ruled in mid- September.
In its decision the court expanded the government's ability to withhold records under Freedom of Information Act exemptions protecting deliberative materials and law enforcement activities.
NEW JERSEY -- A federal judge presiding in the fraud trial of Eddie "Crazy Eddie" Antar has refused to unseal the names and addresses of jurors, purportedly to keep the press from interviewing them. Antar was convicted of securities fraud in late July.
CANADA -- The American media and computer enthusiasts joined forces to disseminate information in two recent cases where the Canadian press has been gagged.
PENNSYLVANIA -- A mid-September meeting of the Fayette County Housing Authority in Uniontown ended in turmoil after the board voted to prohibit the use of video equipment during its meetings.
After the authority unanimously adopted the policy, it adjourned for five minutes to allow the removal of all videocameras. However, a video crew from the Uniontown Herald-Standard refused to leave, citing its right to videotape under the state's Right To Know Law.
SOUTH CAROLINA -- The South Carolina Supreme Court unanimously approved an amendment to the state constitution in late September making cameras in the courtroom permanent after a successful year and a half long experiment.
The South Carolina Press Association and Broadcaster's Steering Committee has worked with the state high court and the State Bar for the past five and a half years on the cameras in courts issue.
PENNSYLVANIA -- A York County judge halted exclusion hearings for immigrants at a local jail Aug. 31 because the facility's rules excluded the public. The hearings were moved to another location and opened the same day.
CALIFORNIA -- U.S. District Court Judge Eugene F. Lynch ordered a new trial in the labyrinthine libel case pitting psychoanalyst Jeffrey M. Masson against author Janet Malcolm. Masson had sued Malcolm for libel, claiming she had fabricated quotes attributed to him in her series published in the New Yorker magazine in 1983.
In his early September ruling, the San Francisco judge also dismissed the New Yorker from the case, and ordered Masson to pay the magazine an estimated $20,000 in court costs, the New York Times reported.