Free press/fair trial

A term commonly used to refer to the delicate balance between the news media's First Amendment right to gather and disseminate information to the public and a criminal defendant's Sixth Amendment right to a public trial by an impartial jury

Maine Supreme Court orders jury selection to be public in prostitution case

Rob Tricchinelli | Secret Courts | News | January 28, 2013
News
January 28, 2013

Maine’s highest court reversed a trial judge's decision and ordered jury selection to be public in a notable prostitution prosecution.

“A generalized concern that juror candor might be reduced if [jury selection] is conducted in public is insufficient . . . to bar the public or media from the entirety of the process,” according to the majority opinion, written by Chief Justice Leigh I. Saufley.

The trial court did not consider other less restrictive alternatives to closure that would still preserve the defendant’s rights, the opinion stated.

Fla. judge denies gag order in Zimmerman case

Lilly Chapa | Secret Courts | News | October 31, 2012
News
October 31, 2012

A Florida judge on Monday denied a proposed gag order that would muzzle all attorneys and law enforcement officers involved in the prosecution of George Zimmerman.

Media organizations challenge gag order in Zimmerman case

Lilly Chapa | Secret Courts | News | October 24, 2012
News
October 24, 2012

More than a dozen news media organizations are opposing a proposed gag order in the George Zimmerman prosecution that would silence all attorneys involved.

OpenCourt can record Mass. jury trials, state high court judge rules

Amanda Simmons | Newsgathering | News | August 15, 2012
News
August 15, 2012

OpenCourt, a Massachusetts courtroom transparency program can begin streaming video of jury trials at a local district court, a judge from the state’s highest court ruled on Tuesday.

Colo. judge upholds majority of sealing and gag orders in Aurora movie theater shooting case

Amanda Simmons | Secret Courts | News | August 14, 2012
News
August 14, 2012

The judge presiding over the fatal Colorado movie theater shooting case granted the release of about three dozen relevant court documents on Monday, but kept many of the records under seal.

Colo. judge weighs news organizations' request to unseal court documents in Aurora shooting trial

Emily Miller | Secret Courts | News | August 10, 2012
News
August 10, 2012

The judge in the shooting-spree case against James Holmes heard arguments Thursday on why court documents should be publicly available, but did not rule on the motion.

More than 20 news organizations are asking Chief District Judge William Sylvester to reconsider his decision to seal court documents in the case against Holmes, accused of killing 12 and wounding 58 people at an Aurora movie theater last month.

Va. court avoids ruling on access to sealed records in child murder case

Kristen Rasmussen | Secret Courts | News | May 25, 2012
News
May 25, 2012

A Virginia appellate court avoided deciding if a newspaper had a right of access to trial exhibits in a child murder case, despite a dissenting judge’s opinion that a procedural issue should not have barred a ruling that sealing the records violated the media’s First Amendment rights.

Judge unseals court records in Trayvon Martin shooting

Rachel Bunn | Secret Courts | News | April 24, 2012
News
April 24, 2012

A Florida judge unsealed court records relating to the case of George Zimmerman - who is charged with the second-degree murder of 17-year-old Trayvon Martin - following legal requests by several news organizations.

Reporter's challenge of sealed arrest warrants provides details about allegations against ex-police officer

Kristen Rasmussen | Secret Courts | News | March 30, 2012
News
March 30, 2012

A Connecticut judge recently unsealed search warrant materials in the case of an ex-police officer charged with dozens of offenses related to his alleged unlawful use of the department’s computer database after a local newspaper reporter challenged the secrecy of the court records.

Strong interest in Ohio public corruption case warrants unsealing of many trial exhibits

Kristen Rasmussen | Secret Courts | Feature | March 23, 2012
Feature
March 23, 2012

A federal judge in Ohio has granted several news media organizations’ request to unseal hundreds of trial exhibits in the racketeering case of an ex-government official.

But U.S. District Judge Sara Lioi declined to immediately release several other exhibits, including recordings of wiretapped conversations, claiming that doing so could affect the appeal and fair-trial rights of James C. Dimora, who is also a defendant in another criminal case alleging substantially similar conduct.