Shield law

Shield laws -- adopted in thirty-nine states and the District of Columbia -- provide varying degrees of protection for reporters from subpoenas. They may provide absolute or qualified protection according to the type of legal proceeding involved (civil or criminal) or the role of the journalist in the proceeding (defendant or independent third party).

Hawaii lawmakers committee pass draft of bill that weakens state reporter shield law

Jack Komperda | Reporter's Privilege | News | April 26, 2013
News
April 26, 2013

A panel of Hawaii lawmakers on Thursday approved a draft that severely limits the soon-expiring state reporter shield law.

The most current version of the bill -- seen as a compromise between House and Senate versions -- removes protections for free newspapers, expands the circumstances under which law enforcement authorities can subpoena journalists’ notes and excludes protections for bloggers.

Hawaii lawmakers set to resume deliberations on state shield law

Jack Komperda | Reporter's Privilege | News | April 22, 2013
News
April 22, 2013

Hawaii lawmakers are expected to meet again this week to work on reconciling competing versions of a bill to make the state’s reporter shield law permanent.

H.B. 622 was originally drafted to remove the law's June 30 expiration date. But lawmakers in both the state House and Senate passed amended versions of the bill limiting who can take advantage of the privilege.

New Jersey blogger considered a journalist under state Shield Law

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | April 16, 2013
News
April 16, 2013

A New Jersey blogger qualifies for protection under the state’s shield law and does not have to reveal the names of government officials she accused of wrongdoing, a judge ruled.

Fox News reporter may return to Colo. courtroom to defend confidential sources

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | April 3, 2013
News
April 3, 2013

Subpoenaed Fox News journalist Jana Winter will have to return to a Colorado courtroom to possibly testify about who gave her sealed information in the James Holmes case, a judge ordered Monday.

However, Arapahoe County District Judge Carlos Samour said in Monday’s hearing that he intends to make Holmes’ lawyers “jump through all the hoops” before forcing Winter to share who gave her details of a notebook Holmes sent to his psychiatrist days before he allegedly opened fire in an Aurora movie theater, killing 12 people.

Fox News reporter scheduled to appear in Colo. courtroom Monday in James Holmes case

Nicole Lozare | Reporter's Privilege | News | March 29, 2013
News
March 29, 2013

A Fox News reporter is scheduled to appear before a Colorado judge on Monday to testify about who leaked her information regarding the notebook of movie theater shooting suspect James Holmes.

Fox News reporter subpoenaed in James Holmes case

Lilly Chapa | Secret Courts | News | March 14, 2013
News
March 14, 2013

A New York judge has signed a subpoena requiring a Fox News reporter to testify in Colorado about who gave her confidential information about a notebook James Holmes sent to his psychiatrist days before he allegedly opened fire on a crowded movie theater last July, killing 12 people.

N.J. judge orders local blogger to defend journalist status

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | February 4, 2013
News
February 4, 2013

A New Jersey Superior Court judge recently ordered a blogger to defend her status as a journalist and explain why the state's shield law applies to her in order to avoid revealing the names of government officials she accused of wrongdoing.

Detroit paper must provide documents and a witness regarding confidential source, judge rules

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | January 18, 2013
News
January 18, 2013

A District Court judge ruled this week that the Detroit Free Press must hand over documents and provide a witness in a long-running case involving former federal prosecutor Richard Convertino and his quest to reveal a reporter’s anonymous source.

Judge Robert Cleland’s ruling requires the Michigan newspaper to turn over documents directly or indirectly related to Convertino and present a witness who can testify at a February deposition for the former prosecutor's lawsuit against the Department of Justice.

Wis. judge denies Justice Department's request to subpoena journalists

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | November 30, 2012
News
November 30, 2012

In the first ruling under Wisconsin’s new shield law, a judge denied the state Department of Justice’s request to subpoena three journalists who reported on a farmer’s alleged criminal conduct .

The justice department was unable to show that the information they seek is unobtainable from other sources, as required by the 2010 law, said Sauk County Judge Guy Reynolds. But Reynolds, who ruled from the bench Thursday, added that he would reconsider the subpoenas if the state's other witnesses contradict the journalists' reports.

Ken Burns team fights for shield law protection over Central Park jogger suit subpoena

Lilly Chapa | Reporter's Privilege | News | October 5, 2012
News
October 5, 2012

Documentary filmmakers are fighting a subpoena that would require them to hand over outtakes and notes, claiming that they are protected under New York's shield law.