Erie Reader v. Millcreek Township Police Department
Court: Erie County Court of Common Pleas
Clients: Erie Reader, Alana Sabol
Background: In August 2026, Erie Reader reporter Alana Sabol filed a public records request seeking roughly eight months of aggregated data showing, among other things, the Millcreek Township Police Department’s reasons for searching records captured by Flock Safety automated license plate reader cameras installed at a local mall.
The proliferation of Flock cameras in communities across the country has prompted widespread backlash over their threat to personal privacy and reports of misuse by law enforcement. As the Reader has reported, residents in Millcreek Township have raised concerns about the cameras and local officials’ lack of transparency about them.
The police department denied Sabol’s request, claiming that the information was exempt from disclosure because it relates to a criminal investigation and because it is protected under the Pennsylvania Criminal History Records Information Act.
Sabol and the Reader appealed the denial to Pennsylvania’s Office of Open Records. In October 2026, the OOR issued a final determination siding with the police department, concluding that the records cannot be released because they concern a criminal investigation.
On behalf of Sabol and the Reader, Reporters Committee attorney Paula Knudsen Burke filed this lawsuit asking the Erie County Court of Common Pleas to reverse the OOR’s decision and order the police department to turn over the requested records. The lawsuit argues that the audit records are not related to a criminal investigation and that they are subject to disclosure under Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law.
Quote: “This type of technology has raised considerable questions from the public, and Pennsylvania’s public records law, the Right-to-Know Law, allows requesters to find out more information about taxpayer-funded equipment such as ALPRs,” Burke told the Reader.
Related: In July 2026, Burke sued the city of Allentown, Pennsylvania, on behalf of The Morning Call seeking similar data related to the city’s searches of its Flock cameras. The case is ongoing.
Filings:
2026-11-12: Petition for review