Skip to content

Judge quashes tobacco company subpoena

Post categories

  1. Protecting Sources and Materials
Judge quashes tobacco company subpoena 08/09/1994 VIRGINIA -- Judge Paul Sheridan of the state circuit court in Arlington in late…

Judge quashes tobacco company subpoena

08/09/1994

VIRGINIA — Judge Paul Sheridan of the state circuit court in Arlington in late July quashed a subpoena through which the Brown & Williamson tobacco company sought documents from USA Today.

In early and mid-May, USA Today and several other news organizations published articles based on revelations said to come from internal Brown & Williamson documents. The information suggested that since 1963 Brown & Williamson might have known that tobacco imperiled health and was addictive, while representing to the public that no such problems existed.

Meanwhile, Brown & Williamson was engaged in civil litigation in Kentucky against a former paralegal of the company’s law firm. Brown & Williamson claims that the former paralegal wrongfully took and photocopied company documents.

At Brown & Williamson’s request, in mid-May the Arlington circuit court issued a subpoena for company documents in the possession of USA Today.

When USA Today refused to cooperate, Brown & Williamson asked the court to order compliance. The court refused, holding that under Virginia case law confidential press materials are protected from civil litigants unless the information is crucial to a claim.

The court found that Brown & Williamson neither demonstrated a need for the information, nor exhausted other means of obtaining it.

USA Today’s briefing included a supporting affidavit from the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.

In a related proceeding, in early June the U.S. district court in Washington, D.C. quashed a Brown & Williamson subpoena to two congressmen. The court held that the congressmen were protected by the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause.

(Maddox v. Williams; Media Counsel: Robert Sack, New York; Theodore Olson, Theodore Boutrous Jr., Washington)

Stay informed by signing up for our mailing list

Keep up with our work by signing up to receive our monthly newsletter. We'll send you updates about the cases we're doing with journalists, news organizations, and documentary filmmakers working to keep you informed.