Skip to content

Federal appeals court blocks broad demand for journalist records in leak investigation

Post categories

  1. National security
“This ruling is a big deal,” said Reporters Committee President Bruce D. Brown.
Credit: “LinkedIn” by Focal Foto is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/deed.en

A federal appeals court has blocked an order requiring LinkedIn to give federal prosecutors metadata on a group of journalists as part of a national security leak investigation, concluding the “substantially overbroad” demand, if upheld, would inappropriately reveal the identities of unrelated confidential sources and “deal a damaging blow to First Amendment freedoms.”

Last week, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit unanimously ruled that a lower court wrongly offered “blanket approval to the government’s broad request” for the journalists’ records. In a 24-page opinion, the appeals court sent the case back to a federal district court to narrow the order, directing it to weigh the government’s national security interest against the First Amendment protections for a free press.

“This ruling is a big deal and will quickly become one of the leading opinions in the area — we will be quoting from it for a long time,” said Reporters Committee President Bruce D. Brown. “The court recognized that confidential sources are the ‘lifeblood’ of investigative reporting and that dragnet demands from technology companies to reveal those sources violate the law.”

Reporters Committee filed a friend-of-the-court brief in the case in August, arguing that the district court’s order, if upheld, could imperil First Amendment protections for newsgathering. The government sought the order as part of a probe into the unauthorized disclosure of classified information published in a news article “purporting to describe a top-secret United States military operation in a foreign country.”

While details about the underlying leak investigation are sealed, news reporting suggests that it may be related to a New York Times article about a failed Navy SEAL Team 6 mission in North Korea during Donald Trump’s first term as president. Earlier this year, the U.S. Department of Justice subpoenaed one of the journalists who reported the story, Matthew Cole, in a bid to uncover his confidential sources. Cole is fighting the subpoena. 

Reporters Committee and The New York Times previously sought to unseal judicial records related to the freelance journalist’s efforts to challenge the subpoena. This week, Reporters Committee filed a friend-of-the-court brief in support of Cole’s motion to quash the subpoena, citing the Fourth Circuit’s recent opinion in arguing that these kinds of overbroad investigative demands are “anathema under the First Amendment.”

“A request by the government to scoop up reporters’ records wholesale and ascertain the identity of their sources would tip the balance against informed discourse in a manner inimical to democratic health,” Fourth Circuit Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III wrote for the panel. 

“Press freedom is among those things viewed by autocrats worldwide as a threat to their grip on power,” Judge Wilkinson continued. “Criminal prosecutions freed from partisanship and retribution, a fearless and independent judicial system, and a secure and accessible electoral process all serve to supplement press freedom in distinguishing liberty from oppression.”

Stay informed by signing up for our monthly newsletter

Keep up with the Reporters Committee by subscribing to our monthly newsletter! We'll send you updates about our work defending the rights of journalists, the latest news on press freedom, original analyses on First Amendment issues, and more.